This post contains affiliate links. We may earn a small commission when you buy through our links — at no extra cost to you.
Choosing a portable fire pit often comes down to fuel type: propane for convenience and near-zero smoke, or wood for the classic campfire experience. But weight, heat output, and included accessories can make or break your setup — especially if you’re packing it into a car or RV.
Propane pits dominate because they light instantly, produce no ash, and work even during moderate burn bans. The trade-off is that you need to haul a propane tank, and manual ignition models require a lighter. Wood pits, on the other hand, need dry wood to truly reduce smoke and demand more cleanup.
The real question is how you’ll use it: for quick weekend car camping, a light propane pit with a carry kit is hard to beat. For long evenings around a real fire, a smokeless wood pit like the Solo Stove Bonfire delivers ambiance without the haze.
Best for No-Mess Smokeless
Outland Living 19" 893 Deluxe
Key Features
- Heat Output: 58,000 BTU
- Weight & Dimensions: 23 lbs, 19x19x11 in
- Fuel: Propane
- Accessories: Cover, carry kit, lava rocks
- Price: Mid-Range
The Outland Living 19-inch Deluxe delivers steady, adjustable heat that warms a circle of chairs without the smoke or ash of wood. The 58,000 BTU output can be turned down to a low flame for ambiance, and the included carry bag and cover make transport and storage straightforward.
Setup is genuinely zero-assembly — attach the propane tank, spread the lava rocks, and light the burner with a separate lighter or match. The manual ignition is the only real tradeoff against pricier push-button models, but it has proven reliable across thousands of users and saves roughly $50.
This fire pit suits campers and families who want a clean, portable heat source without dealing with wood, ash, or complex assembly. It’s not for buyers who prefer a traditional campfire crackle or who want an all-in-one ignition system out of the box.
Pros
- Provides abundant warmth for groups with adjustable flame from low glow to high heat.
- Comes with a padded carry bag, protective cover, and lava rocks so nothing extra is needed.
- Ready to use in minutes with no tools or assembly required.
Cons
- Requires a separate lighter or match to ignite — no push-button start.
- The 23-pound weight and propane tank make it a car-camp item, not for backpacking.
For anyone who values a complete, no-nonsense propane fire pit that works reliably trip after trip, this is the one to buy — just keep a lighter handy.
Best for Easiest Startup
Outland Living 19" 870 Premium
Key Features
- Heat Output: 58,000 BTU
- Weight & Dimensions: 25 lbs, 19x19x11 in
- Fuel: Propane
- Accessories: Cover, carry kit, lava rocks
- Price: Mid-Range
The Outland Living 870 Premium adds auto-ignition to the 19-inch propane pit category, so there is no need to carry a separate lighter. The decorative belt and smooth finish give it a noticeably more polished look than the standard models. At 25 lbs it is the heaviest of the 19-inch options, and the price is higher than the manual version, so this tradeoff matters most for campers who prioritize convenience and appearance over budget or pack weight.
Pros
- Auto-ignition lights the fire with a simple push – no matches or lighters needed.
- Decorative belt and premium construction give it a refined, upscale look.
Cons
- Heavier than other 19-inch propane pits – the 25 lbs is noticeable when carrying longer distances from car to campsite.
If auto-ignition and a polished look are worth the extra weight and cost, this is the right choice.
Best for Wood Fire Purists
Solo Stove Bonfire 2.0
Key Features
- Weight & Dimensions: 21.8 lbs, 19.5×19.5×17.5 in
- Fuel: Wood
- Accessories: Stand
- Price: Premium
The Bonfire’s double-wall design feeds oxygen through secondary air jets, burning off smoke and producing a clean, hot flame with minimal ash. This near-smokeless performance relies on dry wood; green or damp wood will produce noticeable smoke. The premium price reflects the stainless steel build and efficiency, but it’s heavier than many portable propane pits and not suitable for hiking. It’s best for backyard enthusiasts and car campers who enjoy the ritual of a wood fire and have access to dry firewood — not for budget buyers or those who prefer the convenience of propane.
Pros
- Smokeless performance after startup — significantly less smoke than traditional campfires
- Burns efficiently with fine ash for easy cleanup
Cons
If you have a steady supply of dry firewood and value a near-smokeless wood fire experience, the Bonfire delivers on its engineering promise — just don’t expect it to work with damp wood or compete with propane on convenience.
Best for Budget Car Campers
Fireside Pop-Up 24"
Key Features
- Weight & Dimensions: 8 lbs, 24x24x15 in
- Fuel: Wood
- Accessories: Carry bag
- Price: Budget
At 8 pounds and collapsing to a flat disk, this pit stows in a cargo corner or trunk with ease. The pop-up frame snaps open in seconds, making it one of the quickest campfires to light. That portability comes with a deliberate trade: the mesh screen and heat shield are lightweight and can wear with frequent use – heavy campers may see holes after a few trips. For occasional weekenders who pack a small car, the weight savings are worth the compromise.
This pit is built for car campers who prioritize packability over longevity. If you need a fire pit for a handful of trips each season and want to save trunk space, this design fits the bill. Budget-friendly at under $100, it gives you a real wood fire without bulk. Just note that the screen and heat shield are not made for daily burns or rocky ground – moderate use keeps them intact longer.
Pros
- Collapses to a slim disk for easy storage
- Pop-up frame sets up in under a minute, no tools
Cons
- Mesh screen and heat shield can wear out after repeated use – less of an issue for occasional campers
- Smoke production depends on wood moisture; not a smokeless design
Top choice for car campers who need a fire pit that disappears into a duffle bag – just accept the durability limits for light, seasonal use.
Best for Lightest Propane
Bond Aurora 18.5" Propane
Key Features
- Heat Output: 54,000 BTU
- Weight & Dimensions: 18 lbs, 18.5×18.5×14.7 in
- Fuel: Propane
- Price: Mid-Range
At 18 pounds with a built-in handle and locking lid, this Bond Aurora pit is noticeably lighter than comparable models — a real advantage when loading gear for a camping trip. The bottom stays cool enough for safe use on wood decks, expanding where you can place it.
This setup suits campers who want a compact propane pit they can grab and go. The manual ignition uses a piezo sparker that can stop working after initial use, so packing a backup lighter is smart — not a dealbreaker for experienced users who already carry one.
Pros
- Locking lid and carry handle make this easy to grab and go.
- Cool-to-touch bottom allows safe placement on wood decks.
Cons
- Piezo sparker may stop working after initial use, requiring a backup lighter.
For campers who prioritize weight and deck safety over auto-ignition, this Bond Aurora delivers — just keep a lighter handy.
Best for Rv Storage
Outland Firecube 14" Square
Key Features
- Heat Output: 58,000 BTU
- Weight & Dimensions: 22.5 lbs, 14x14x9 in
- Fuel: Propane
- Accessories: Cover, carry straps
- Price: Mid-Range
The square 14-inch shape makes the Firecube unusually space-efficient — it slides into RV compartments and car trunks where round pits won’t fit. Despite its compact footprint, the 58,000 BTU output provides enough heat for two people. At 22.5 lbs, the Firecube is heavier than its size suggests, so it’s best suited for vehicle-based camping rather than backpacking.
Pros
- Compact square shape fits easily in vehicle storage
- High heat output for its small size
Cons
- Heavier than expected at 22.5 lbs, not for hiking
This square pit is the right choice for RV owners who need to maximize storage space, as long as you’re okay with the weight.
Best for Stylish Wood Pit
TIKI Social 20" Fire Pit
Key Features
- Weight & Dimensions: 32 lbs, 25.5×25.5×17.7 in
- Fuel: Wood
- Price: Mid-Range
This 32-pound wood pit uses thick stainless steel and a powder-coated finish that resists rust, and once burning with dry wood, smoke output is noticeably low. However, the weight makes it more suited for car camping or backyard use than backpacking, and wet wood or initial startup produces visible smoke—not the complete burn-off of lighter competitors.
Pros
- Produces minimal smoke when burning seasoned wood.
- 16-gauge stainless steel with powder coating feels solid and looks polished.
Cons
- The 32-pound heft limits its portability to car camping or stationary use.
Best for car campers or backyard owners who prioritize a durable, attractive wood pit over ultra-light portability and true smokeless performance.
Best for Large Propane
Flame King 24" Propane
Key Features
- Heat Output: 58,000 BTU
- Weight & Dimensions: 27.3 lbs, 24x24x12 in
- Fuel: Propane
- Price: Mid-Range
The Flame King 24-inch propane pit delivers strong heat output and push-button ignition for easy startup. However, some units show paint chips or dents upon arrival, and the carry strap may tear after a few uses—acceptable for buyers prioritizing size and price over flawless cosmetics.
Pros
- Auto-ignition starts the fire with a simple push button.
- 58,000 BTU output warms a group of about 10 people.
Cons
- Finish defects like dents or chipped paint may appear on some units.
A solid pick if you need a large propane pit on a tight budget and can accept possible cosmetic blemishes.
Best for Tabletop Ambiance
Solo Stove Mesa XL
Key Features
- Weight & Dimensions: 2.3 lbs, 7x7x8.6 in
- Fuel: Wood/pellets
- Price: Budget
Weighing just 2.3 lbs, the Mesa XL packs easily for solo camp trips or balcony tables. Its very small flame provides no practical heat, and smoke can appear with certain fuels — this is for tabletop ambiance, not for warmth or cooking.
Pros
- Weighs only 2.3 lbs for easy transport in a backpack or car.
- Accepts both wood and pellets for flexible fueling.
Cons
- Flame is not large enough to warm more than one person or cook food.
Best for solo campers or couples who want a tiny campfire for s’mores on a tabletop — not for heating or cooking.
Best for Compact Wood
Solo Stove Ranger 2.0
Key Features
- Weight & Dimensions: 16.5 lbs, 17x17x15 in
- Fuel: Wood
- Price: Premium
The Ranger 2.0 uses the same 360-degree airflow design found in larger Solo Stove models, producing a near-smokeless fire with properly dried wood. Its 15-inch diameter keeps it compact and easy to transport, but the small fire limits heat output to about two to four people. At a premium price per inch, the larger Bonfire offers better value for groups.
Pros
- Smokeless burn from 360-degree airflow design
- Portable and well-built for its size
Cons
- Small fire limits heat and cooking space for more than 2-4 people
For solo campers or couples who value a smokeless experience and can tolerate a compact fire, the Ranger 2.0 is a capable choice – but groups should look to the Bonfire for better value.
Best for Novelty Fire
Radiate XL 8" Wax Fire
Key Features
- Weight & Dimensions: 1 lb, 8 in dia
- Fuel: Soy wax
- Accessories: Lid
- Price: Budget
The Radiate XL delivers a quick, no-mess fire from a 1 lb soy wax disc that lights easily and leaves no ash. However, the burn time often falls short of the claimed 2 hours, and the smoke carries a petroleum-like odor that can be unpleasant in calm conditions. This is not a heat source for serious campers — it’s a compact ambiance piece for short outings where weight is the primary concern.
Pros
- Extremely portable and easy to use – just light and enjoy
- No ash or mess, reusable with lid
Cons
- Smoke may be significant and carry a petroleum-like odor, noticeable in calm conditions
A fun novelty for beach or tailgate use where weight is critical, but the short burn time and smoke limit it to quick ambience sessions — not a primary fire source.
How to Choose
The most important decision is fuel type: propane gives you instant, smokeless convenience, while wood provides ambiance and lower cost per burn but requires more tending.
Heat Output (BTU)
BTU directly determines how much warmth the pit can throw. A 58,000 BTU propane pit can comfortably heat a circle of six to eight people on a cool evening. Lower BTU ratings (like 54,000) mean slightly less heat, but the difference is often negligible for casual use.
For wood pits, BTU is rarely listed because heat output depends on wood size and moisture. The burn chamber design matters more: a 360-degree airflow pattern (like Solo Stove) improves combustion and radiates heat outward more effectively.
Weight and Dimensions
Weight directly affects portability. Pits under 15 lbs can be carried by hand without strain; those over 25 lbs are best for rolling or short distances. A 23-26 lb propane pit is fine for car camping but not for hiking.
Dimensions matter for storage: round pits take up more awkward space, while square or collapsible designs (like the Firecube or Fireside Pop-Up) slide into tight compartments. Always measure your trunk or RV storage before buying.
Fuel Type
Propane is the most convenient: it lights instantly, produces no ash or smoke, and works during most fire bans (check local rules). However, you need to carry a 20 lb tank, which adds about 18 lbs of weight.
Wood gives a more authentic campfire experience and costs less per use, especially if you gather wood on site. But you must tend the fire, deal with ash, and ensure wood is dry to minimize smoke. Smokeless wood pits reduce smoke but never eliminate it completely.
Ignition Type
Manual ignition requires a lighter or match to light the gas. It’s simple and reliable, but you can lose the lighter in the dark. Auto-ignition (piezo) lights with a twist of a knob — a convenience for frequent users, though the sparker can fail over time.
For wood pits, ignition is always manual (kindling and a lighter). Some models include a built-in sparker, but it’s not standard. A fire starter block or long-reach lighter is recommended.
Included Accessories
A carry kit (bag or straps) and weather cover add real value, especially if you travel often. Lava rocks or fire glass are standard with propane pits — they help distribute heat and glow nicely. Without them, you’ll need to buy separately.
Some wood pits include a carry case or stand (like Solo Stove). Collapsible pits often come with a storage bag. Check the package: a missing cover means you’ll have to shield the pit from rain or store it indoors.
FAQ
Can I use a portable propane fire pit during a burn ban?
It depends on local restrictions. Many jurisdictions allow propane fire pits because they produce no sparks or embers, but some ban all open flames including propane during extreme fire danger. Always check with your local fire department or park ranger before relying on a propane pit during a ban.
How long does a 20 lb propane tank last on a portable fire pit?
At full output (58,000 BTU), a 20 lb tank lasts roughly 8-10 hours. On lower settings, you can stretch that to 12-15 hours. For a weekend camping trip, one tank is usually enough for evening use. Higher BTU pits consume fuel faster, so adjust accordingly.
Is a smokeless fire pit really smokeless?
No fire pit is completely smokeless. Smokeless designs use secondary combustion (like 360-degree airflow) to burn off most smoke, but they still produce visible smoke during startup, when wood is damp, or if fuel is too large. With dry, seasoned wood and proper feeding, the smoke is minimal — often 80-90% less than a traditional campfire.
What’s the best portable fire pit for backpacking or hiking?
For backpacking, weight and packability are critical. The Solo Stove Mesa XL (2.3 lbs) or the Fireside Pop-Up (8 lbs) are the lightest options, but neither provides substantial heat for a group. The Radiate XL wax fire (1 lb) is even lighter but burns briefly and can be smoky. Most hikers prefer a small wood-burning stove rather than a traditional fire pit for multi-day trips.