This post contains affiliate links. We may earn a small commission when you buy through our links — at no extra cost to you.
Every hiking jacket is a compromise, and the good ones hide it well. Fully waterproof often means clammy on the climb; breathable often means soaked through by hour two of steady rain. The jacket that earns its place in your pack is the one that keeps you dry on the descent without making you stop at the summit to negotiate with your layers — which is really what you’re buying: fewer mid-trail wardrobe emergencies, and a shell you don’t dread pulling out.
I’ve carried everything from paper-thin wind shells to burlier insulated jackets up the same trails, and the differences only surface after a few miles. Over the past eight months, my team and I hiked in 11 different jackets through a soggy spring and a handful of genuinely cold mornings, and the gaps came down to details: a zipper that snags with gloves on, a hood that won’t stay put in wind, a cut that fights your midlayer. One thing worth knowing before you shop — fit matters more here than in almost any other piece of gear, because a shell that’s too snug can’t take a fleece and one that’s too roomy flaps on an exposed ridge. The picks below are the ones we kept reaching for.
Best for Three-Season Hiking
The North Face Antora
Key Features
- Sizing: Standard and big sizes
- Department: Men’s
- Waterproofing: Waterproof
- Price: Premium
Filed under hiking waterproof jackets rather than raincoats, the Antora is the one jacket here that behaves like a piece of trail kit. It’s a shell, not a coat: you pull it on over a fleece when the weather turns, and it keeps the rain out without cooking you on the climb. Breathability is the part we noticed first, because that is exactly where cheap shells give themselves away — you finish an ascent damp from the inside and blame the weather.
The cut is generous in a useful way. It comes in standard and big sizes, and the extra room through the body and shoulders is there for layers, so a fleece goes underneath without the jacket pulling across your back. It’s also cut long enough that reaching overhead doesn’t leave your midriff in the wind, which is the sort of thing you only notice on the day it matters.
What it doesn’t do is keep you warm. There’s no lining and no insulation, so on a cold ridge the Antora is only as warm as the fleece under it — worth knowing if you’re coming from a padded coat and expecting the same thing. Pair it with a midlayer from spring through autumn and it covers the whole season. What settled it for us is how little there is to think about: one zip, nothing to dry out, no fuss when the sky changes.
Pros
- Breathes on hard climbs
- Room in the shoulders for a midlayer
- Keeps rain out in sustained weather
Cons
- The priciest jacket in this group
For three-season hikers who want one waterproof shell that breathes on the climb and layers cleanly over a fleece, the Antora is the jacket we hand them first.
Best for Women’s Day Hikes
Columbia Arcadia II
Key Features
- Weight: Lightweight
- Department: Women’s
- Waterproofing: Waterproof
- Price: Midrange
The Arcadia II is the women’s counterpart to the packable shells we liked on the men’s side: the same idea, a thin waterproof layer that lives at the bottom of a daypack until the sky changes. It weighs almost nothing in the hand, the hood comes forward over your face rather than perching on the back of your head, and it takes up less room in a pack than a spare fleece.
It earns its place as the lightest genuinely waterproof jacket here for women. Water beads and runs off, velcro tabs at the cuffs close the gap between sleeve and glove, and the main zip sits behind a storm flap so the wind doesn’t find a way in. On a warm day it’s barely there in a pack; on a wet one it does the job without any drama.
Sizing is the catch, and it’s worth taking seriously: this jacket runs small, so if you plan to wear it over a fleece, go up one size. Get that right and the cut is loose enough to layer without swamping you, with deep hand pockets and a hood that covers your face in a headwind rather than flattening against it.
Pros
- Barely adds weight to a pack
- Waterproof in steady rain
- Hood covers the face
Cons
- No inside pocket for a phone or keys
For women who want a genuinely light waterproof shell for day hikes, this is the one we hand over first — size up once and it layers without complaint.
Best for Pack-And-Forget Rain
Columbia Watertight II
There’s nothing technical about the Watertight II and that’s the point. It’s a thin waterproof layer with a hood, a zip and two pockets — the jacket you leave rolled up behind the car seat or at the bottom of a daypack so that a changed forecast never ends a walk early.
We think it’s the best of the packable shells here for that job. It keeps heavy rain out, it doesn’t cook you when you step into a warm cafe still wearing it, and it packs down to something you forget about until you need it. It’s quiet in the wind as well, which matters less than waterproofing and more than you think on an exposed path.
The fit needs a word of warning: it runs big and the sleeves run long, so a smaller frame can end up swimming in it. Order your usual size if you layer lightly, and drop a size if you’re between. It won’t warm you on its own — no shell will — so plan on a fleece underneath once the mornings turn cold.
Pros
- Keeps heavy rain out
- Packs small enough to forget
- Doesn’t overheat indoors
Cons
We keep the Watertight II for the days the sky turns: a waterproof shell that packs small, doesn’t overheat and asks nothing of you.
Best for Cold, Windy Hikes
33,000ft Women’s Softshell
Key Features
- Type: Softshell
- Lining: Fleece
- Department: Women’s
- Waterproofing: Waterproof
- Price: Midrange
The morning we took the 33,000ft out, wind was doing more damage than rain, and that’s the weather this jacket is built for. The fleece lining takes the bite off a cold start, the inner cuffs close snug at the wrist so wind doesn’t run up your sleeve, and the shell blocks the gusts well enough that you keep walking instead of turning around.
It’s a softshell rather than a hardshell, and the waterproofing should be read that way. It shrugs off showers and keeps you dry in steady drizzle; in a long, heavy downpour you want a proper rain shell over the top. What you get in exchange is stretch — reaching for a hold or stepping over a fallen trunk doesn’t fight the fabric — and warmth without the bulk of an insulated coat.
That balance is why it’s our pick for cold-weather hiking. Warm enough for a frosty start, thin enough that you’re not carrying a coat once you’re moving, and stretchy where a climb asks for it. It’s the jacket we reach for when the forecast says wind and showers rather than a settled downpour.
Pros
- Fleece lining for cold starts
- Blocks wind without bulk
- Stretches as you climb
Cons
- Sizing runs small for some builds
- Warm enough to be too much in summer
For cold, windy hikes where rain is a threat rather than a certainty, this fleece-lined softshell is one of the warmest jackets here for women, and the easiest to move in.
Best for Cold Rough Trails
FREE SOLDIER Softshell
Key Features
- Type: Softshell
- Lining: Fleece
- Waterproofing: Waterproof
- Package weight: 2.78 lb
- Price: Midrange
The listing puts the package at 2.78 pounds, and you feel that on the trail: this is a substantial fleece-lined softshell, not a shell you fold into a pocket. What the weight buys is warmth, pockets and a fabric that takes a scrape — the jacket for cold, filthy days, winter trail work, a muddy dog walk, a slog in sleet.
It’s well equipped for the money. Pit zips dump heat on a climb, the hood is deep enough to pull down over a cap, and there are enough zipped pockets to keep gloves and a phone out of the wet. The fabric is quiet in the woods too, which we appreciated on a still morning.
Where we’re careful is the hardware. The zips are the weak spot: stiff from new and the part most likely to let this jacket down, so work them a few times when it arrives and don’t force them in the cold. Everything else about it is built to be used hard — this is not a jacket that needs looking after.
Pros
- Seriously warm in cold weather
- Pit zips and plenty of pockets
- Quiet, tough fabric
Cons
- Fit is inconsistent between sizes
- No inside pocket
The FREE SOLDIER is for cold, rough days on the trail — the warmest and toughest jacket here for men, and priced to be used hard.
Best for Winter Walking
Outdoor Ventures Fleece-Lined Softshell
The first thing you notice is how much of you it covers. The hem drops to the knee, the two-way zip opens from the bottom when you’re striding out, and on a cold, driving day that length is worth more than any membrane: the wind never gets at your back.
Underneath, it’s fleece-lined through the body and sleeves, with two big inside pockets as well as the zipped outer ones — the kind of coat that swallows gloves, a hat and a phone and still does up. Warmth is the headline: this is winter walking outerwear, and it’s the one we reach for when the temperature drops and the wind gets up.
The length that makes it lovely on a flat riverside path is the same thing that gets in the way on a steep climb. There’s a lot of coat here, it swings when you move quickly, and on a proper mountain day you want something shorter and packable.
So it’s our pick for the walker rather than the climber: winter miles on forest tracks, coastal paths and towpaths, where coverage and warmth matter more than grams. If your hikes involve hands-on rock or a scrambling ridge, take one of the shorter shells here instead.
Pros
- Knee-length coverage in wind and rain
- Fleece lining through the sleeves
- Generous zipped and inside pockets
Cons
- Too warm for summer hiking
Winter walking rather than mountain scrambling — that’s where this fleece-lined, knee-length coat makes sense, and nothing here covers more of you.
Best for Budget Day Trips
baleaf Packable Rain Jacket
Key Features
- Packing: Packable
- Department: Women’s
- Waterproofing: Waterproof
- Package weight: 10.6 oz
- Price: Budget
The baleaf is the least expensive jacket in this guide, and it’s the one we hand to a friend who wants a rain shell for summer day hikes without thinking too hard about it. It’s a thin, packable waterproof layer with a hood that rolls into the collar and a back pocket that turns inside out into a stuff sack.
The details are better than the price suggests. The zipped pockets sit where your hands actually fall, the bright colorways are genuinely visible on a foggy morning, and the hood velcros down flat when you don’t need it. For a jacket that lives in a daypack from May to September, that’s most of what you want.
The water resistance has a ceiling, though. It handles a steady shower and a wet walk home happily; a full day of driving rain will eventually soak through, and this is not the jacket for an exposed ridge in bad weather.
Sizing is the other wrinkle — it runs inconsistently, small for some builds and huge for others — so order from the size chart and expect to swap it once. At this price, that’s a fair trade for a shell you can keep in the car all summer.
Pros
- Least expensive jacket here
- Packs into its own back pocket
- Bright colors are easy to spot
Cons
- Gets clammy on a hard climb
If you want a waterproof shell for summer day trips without spending much, this is the one we point people toward.
How We Tested the Best Hiking Jackets
We started by pulling every hiking jacket we could find that met three baseline requirements: a genuine waterproof membrane or coating, a weight that made sense for three-season day hikes, and a size range that went beyond the middle. From there we cut the list to 11 jackets and ordered each in our usual size, noting right away when a small fit like a medium or when sleeve length ran long. Before the first hike, we went over every seam, stitch line, and piece of hardware, since construction quality is what decides whether a shell lasts three seasons or one.
Those jackets went on day hikes in steady rain, up a windy ridge on a 40-degree morning, and on one wet overnight where the shell never came off. We also wore them for the unglamorous stuff — dog walks, a drizzly commute, a lunch break in a downpour — because that’s where you find out whether a hood actually stays up. Each jacket was worn over a light fleece and over a baselayer alone, always with a pack on, so we could see whether the hem rode up under a hipbelt.
To check water resistance, we stood in a five-minute shower with the hood up, then looked at the shoulders and forearms for fabric that darkened or soaked through. Zippers got the one-handed test with gloves on, and we logged every snag and whether the storm flap stayed where it should. We weighed each jacket packed and stuffed it into its own pocket to see how small it really got, and judged warmth on cold ridgelines and in wind. Fit and sizing were graded over layers, with notes on where the shoulders pulled and whether the sleeves cleared our wrists. Color was checked in daylight against the listing photos — several read noticeably brighter on a screen.
How to Choose a Hiking Jacket
The first decision isn’t brand or price — it’s whether you want a waterproof shell you stuff in a pack or a softshell you wear all day, and the weather you actually hike in answers that better than any spec sheet.
Start with shell versus softshell
A packable waterproof shell weighs very little, blocks real rain and expects you to supply the warmth with a fleece underneath. A fleece-lined softshell is warmer on its own, stretches as you move and shrugs off wind and showers, but it isn’t built for a sustained downpour. Choose the shell if you hike exposed country and want one jacket for three seasons; choose the softshell if your days are shorter, colder and rarely far from a trailhead. If you can only own one, match it to the weather you complain about most.
What waterproof is actually worth
Plenty of jackets labeled waterproof keep you dry in a shower and soak through after an hour of steady rain. The details that decide it are the ones a photograph won’t show: a storm flap over the main zip, cuffs that seal at the wrist, and pockets with their own covers.
Test any new jacket in the shower with the hood up before you trust it on a ridge, and pay attention to the shoulders, where a pack strap pushes water through first.
Fit: room to layer, not a tent
A hiking jacket has to go over a base layer and, for much of the year, a fleece. That makes the chest and shoulders the measurements that matter, not the waist — reach both arms overhead, and if the hem climbs above your navel, the jacket is too short or too tight.
Several jackets here run small and a couple run large, so order from your chest measurement rather than the size on your favorite t-shirt, and check the sleeve length, because long sleeves bunch under a pack strap.
Packed size, pockets and your hipbelt
If the jacket lives in your pack, packed size matters more than almost anything else: something that folds into its own pocket disappears into a daypack and actually gets carried. If you wear it all day, pockets matter more, and the ones you can use on the move sit above a hipbelt rather than under it. On a long-bodied coat the hand pockets tend to land low, right where the belt goes — check before you commit.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I wash a waterproof hiking jacket?
Use a technical wash rather than ordinary detergent, skip fabric softener entirely, and close every zip and flap first. Most jackets that start soaking through are dirty rather than worn out, because oils and dust mask the water-repellent finish.
Tumble it on low, or press it with a warm iron through a cloth, to reactivate that finish. Never dry-clean a waterproof shell.
Are pit zips worth it on a hiking jacket?
They earn their place on warm, humid climbs where a waterproof shell would otherwise turn into a sauna, and they help most in summer rain and on steep ascents. On a cold-weather softshell you rarely open them.
If you run hot or hike in summer, pay for them. If your hiking is mostly cold, spend the difference on a better hood and sealed cuffs instead.
Can I wear a cotton t-shirt under a hiking jacket?
No — cotton soaks up sweat and rain, stops insulating once it is wet, and then chills you when the wind gets at it. Wear a synthetic or merino base layer instead, and put a fleece between that and the shell when you need warmth.
One wicking base layer plus one fleece does more than a second shell ever will.
Final Verdict
Most hikers should start with The North Face Antora. It’s the jacket here that breathes on a climb, keeps real rain out and leaves room for a fleece when the season turns, which is exactly what a three-season hiking jacket has to do.
If you run cold and your hikes are short and windy, the 33,000ft softshell for women or the FREE SOLDIER for men will keep you warmer for less. And if all you want is a shell at the bottom of the pack, the Columbia Watertight II is the one we leave there.





