This post contains affiliate links. We may earn a small commission when you buy through our links — at no extra cost to you.
Mile six of a muggy July long run is a bad place to discover your shorts have been creeping upward since mile two. I’ve retired plenty of pairs mid-training-cycle — ones that chafed, ones whose liner bunched into a rope, ones that went sheer the moment the sun came out. What you actually want is for shorts to be the least interesting thing you put on: a waistband that stays flat, a pocket that holds a phone without dragging one hip down, and fabric that doesn’t turn see-through when you sweat through it. The catch is that 2-inch splits, 5-inch bikers, and 7-inch compression pairs all solve different problems, and the length that feels right for intervals can feel wrong at mile ten.
Nobody warns you that sizing is barely standardized — I’ve been a small in one brand and a medium in another in the same week, and the liner is usually the reason. We ran in 14 pairs over five months, mixing track intervals, long weekend efforts, and gym sessions; plenty looked sharp in the mirror and fell apart at mile eight. The ones that made the list did not.
Best for Everyday Running
Under Armour Play Up 3.0
Key Features
- Fabric: Midweight knit
- Sizing: Runs large
- Pockets: Hand pockets fit a phone
The Play Up 3.0 does not look like a running short. It’s a loose, slightly structured knit with a wide elastic band, closer to a gym short than to a race brief, and it’s still the pair we recommend first. What earned it the top spot is how little it asks of you: the band sits flat, nothing demands attention mid-run, and the hand pockets are deep enough for a phone and a key.
Sizing is the thing to get right. These run large, and the gap between sizes is wide enough that ordering your usual number can leave you swimming in fabric. Our advice is to go down one, especially if you’re using them for speed work rather than errands. Length is the other split — they land mid-thigh on most of us, but the taller runners here wanted another inch at the back.
The knit is a touch heavier than the drill fabric most running shorts use, which is why these go straight from a hard effort to lunch without a sweat map. That thickness isn’t consistent across the range: the blaze orange is the one to skip if coverage matters, because it reads sheer in daylight. The darker colors are the safer bet.
One more detail worth knowing before you order: the logo is the first thing to go. It peels with washing long before the fabric shows any wear, which doesn’t change the fit but does make a good short look older than it is. Wash cold, skip the dryer, and the knit keeps its shape.
Pros
- Wide band sits flat and doesn’t roll
- Hand pockets swallow a phone and keys
- Thicker knit hides sweat marks
- Keeps its looks through repeated washing
Cons
- Runs large; order a size down
- Blaze orange colorway reads sheer
For most runners, this is the pair to buy first: forgiving through the hip, comfortable in heat, and equipped with pockets that hold a phone.
Best for High-Rise Everyday Runs
CRZ YOGA Dolphin 3"
We spent a full session of intervals in the Dolphin and never once touched the waistband. That’s the pitch: a high-rise band that sits flat against the belly, and a three-inch leg with a curved dolphin hem that stays where it lands, including on the thicker-thighed runners among us.
Of the high-waisted shorts here, this is the one we recommend. The fabric is soft with a bit of stretch and a matte finish, the cut flatters without clamping, and it has held both shape and color through repeated washing. The compromise is the pocket: one small side pocket rather than two, and a large phone won’t fit — a key and a gel will.
Sizing splits the difference. Some of us took our usual number and were happy; the band is generous enough that a smaller waist can size down. If your waist is much narrower than your hips, take the smaller of your two sizes. Everything else is quiet competence, at a mid-range price rather than a premium one.
Pros
- High-rise band stays put during hard efforts
- Doesn’t ride up between the thighs
- Soft, stretchy fabric with a flattering hem
- Holds color and shape in the wash
Cons
- One small pocket; large phones don’t fit
Our high-rise pick: soft, stretchy, and stays where you put it, provided you can live with a single small pocket.
Best for Chafe-Free Long Runs
Stelle 2-in-1 Running Shorts
The liner is the whole reason to buy these. The Stelle is a two-in-one — a loose outer shell over a soft, fitted under short — and that under short is what keeps the inner thigh from meeting itself at mile six. We noticed it most on hot, long efforts, where a brief-lined short starts to feel like work.
Four pockets is two more than most shorts here manage: zips on the outer layer and slip pockets in the liner. The outer zip holds a phone; the liner pocket holds a key. The liner is also the thing to size around, because it runs snug, so if you’re between sizes take the larger or you’ll feel it at the waist. At the budget end of this group, nothing else covers this much ground.
Pros
- Under short stops inner-thigh rub
- Four pockets, two of them zipped
- Soft, light fabric against the skin
- Low price for a two-in-one
Cons
- Snug liner; size up if between sizes
The pair we hand to anyone who chafes: a soft under short that stays put, four pockets, and a price at the low end of this group.
Best for Coverage on Trails
baleaf 7" Long Running Shorts
Every other short here shows more leg. Seven inches puts the hem closer to mid-thigh than to the hip, and that changes who this is for: runners who want coverage, tall runners tired of a hem sitting at the widest part of the thigh, and anyone running trails where the brush comes in close.
The waistband is the piece we appreciate most — a wide elastic band with a drawstring, so it stays where you tie it even with a phone weighting one side. The side pockets are the deepest of the shorts we recommend, and there’s a small zip pocket at the center back for a key. For long runs, that combination is hard to beat.
The fabric is thinner than the length suggests: a light ripstop that dries fast and packs small, though it feels crisp rather than soft against the skin. We count that as the trade rather than a fault — you get coverage and quick drying, and you give up some hand-feel. The drawstring isn’t a gimmick either, because a phone in a side pocket will drag an elastic waist down over a long effort.
Sizing follows the usual pattern for this brand, with some of us needing to go up a step; the drawstring forgives it. It’s the most expensive short in this guide, and what you’re paying for is the length and the pocket layout, not a luxury fabric.
Pros
- True seven-inch coverage
- Drawstring keeps a loaded waistband up
- Deepest side pockets here, plus a rear zip
- Dries fast and packs small
Cons
- Crisp, thin fabric isn’t soft on skin
For coverage without a Bermuda silhouette, this is the pair: a true seven-inch running short with the deepest side pockets here.
Best for Hot-Weather Runs
Ksmien 5"/7" Running Shorts
Five inches is the length we kept coming back to in heat. It clears the widest part of the thigh without turning into a walking short, and it’s the Ksmien’s default — there’s a seven-inch version if you want more, and both come with zip pockets.
For humid summer running, this is the pair we recommend. The fabric is thin and dries fast, the waistband is a wide elastic band that sits flat, and the zip pockets on both hips are deep enough for a phone, which most five-inch shorts don’t offer. The trade is structure: with a phone in one pocket, expect the band to shift a little on longer efforts.
Sizing is the muddle here. It runs big through the waist and closer to true through the hip, which is awkward if you’re straight through the middle; take the smaller of your two sizes and let the elastic do the rest. On price it sits near the bottom of this group, which makes it the low-risk way to find out whether a five-inch leg suits you.
Pros
- Dries fast in humid heat
- Two zip pockets hold a phone
- Five- and seven-inch options
- Wide elastic band sits flat
Cons
- Runs big through the waist
Our hot-weather pick: a thin, fast-drying five-inch short with two deep zip pockets, best for tall runners and anyone who wants more leg.
Best for Classic Race Fit
Tough Mode 3" Running Shorts
If you learned to run in a loose mesh short with a liner, the Tough Mode will feel like that short with the details finally sorted. Three-inch leg, mesh liner, a zip pocket, and a waistband that sits below the ribs instead of hauling everything up to them.
The waistband is the part we liked most. It’s wide and soft, and it sits a little lower than the high-rise shorts here, which is the difference between a short you wear for a workout and one you keep on afterward. The zip pocket is genuinely usable, and the fabric is thicker and more structured than the thin quick-dry shells elsewhere in this guide.
Where it gets fiddly is the fit. The waist runs small while the legs run generous, which suits a straighter figure better than a curvy one — an hourglass shape ends up with a band that grips and a hem that floats. For everyone else it’s a quietly excellent short at a mid-range price, and the liner stays put through a whole session.
Pros
- Classic three-inch race cut
- Wide soft band sits lower than high-rise
- Zip pocket for a key or gel
- Liner stays put without riding up
Cons
- Waist runs small while legs run big
The closest thing here to a classic racing short: three inches, a mesh liner, and a waistband that sits below the ribs rather than at them.
Best for Short Gym Sessions
BMJL 2.5" High-Waisted Shorts
There is one pocket, and it’s on the left. That sounds like a small thing until you’ve spent a run patting your right hip, and it’s the detail that separates this short from the rest of the high-waisted pack.
Everything else is conventional in the good sense: a 2.5-inch leg, a wide high band that covers the lower belly, and a light fabric that dries quickly. The waistband is the piece to flag, because it’s firm and the knit has less stretch than most shorts here, so it runs small — go up if you’re between sizes.
It’s the least expensive short in this guide, and it doesn’t feel like it: the zip runs smoothly, the band is lined, and nothing scratches. What you give up is refinement — the leg is a little boxier than the CRZ YOGA, and one pocket means a phone rides on one hip for the whole run.
Buy it if you want a high-waisted short for short runs and gym days without spending much to find out whether the shape suits you. Push it into long distances and the firm band and the single pocket start to tell.
Pros
- Least expensive short in this guide
- Wide high band covers the lower belly
- Light, quick-drying fabric
- Smooth zip and lined waistband
Cons
- One pocket, left hip only
- Firm, low-stretch fit runs small
The budget pick that doesn’t feel budget: a high-waisted 2.5-inch short for short runs and gym days, with one phone-sized zip pocket.
Best for Shortest Option
Blooming Jelly 1.75" Running Shorts
Key Features
- Rise: High-waisted
- Inseam: 1.75 in
- Pockets: Side pocket plus zip
- Price: Budget
The scalloped front hem and the tie-dye are why this one catches the eye. It’s the shortest short here at an inch and three-quarters, and that curved hem is what keeps the length from reading as a plain brief with a waistband sewn on.
The pockets are better than the length suggests: a side pocket that takes a large phone and a small zip pocket for a key. That’s unusual on a short this short, and it’s why these stayed in the rotation for fast sessions instead of being written off as beachwear.
Sizing is where they fall down. The liner is the tightest of any short here and the whole pair runs small, so going up a size is standard advice — which also buys back a little length. The waistband sits high, high enough that it changes which tops work with them.
If you want the shortest leg in this guide and you like the look, these are fun — order up, and treat the snug liner as part of the deal. If you want one pair of shorts for everything, they aren’t it; the coverage is genuinely minimal.
Pros
- Shortest 1.75-inch leg here
- Side pocket fits a large phone
- Scalloped hem and tie-dye prints
- Budget price for a printed short
Cons
- Runs small with the tightest liner here
- Minimal coverage at 1.75 inches
For runners who want the shortest leg here and a print to go with it — order up a size and expect a snug liner.
How We Tested Women’s Running Shorts
We started by gathering more than 60 pairs, from budget two-in-ones to pricier compression shorts, and whittled the list down by length (2, 3, 5, and 7 inch), liner style, size range, and whether the pockets could realistically carry a phone. That left 14 pairs, which four runners on the team wore over five months.
Every pair went through the same rotation: Tuesday track intervals, a Saturday long run of 8 to 14 miles, one treadmill session, and a gym day. We took notes on when we had to stop and tug a hem, whether the liner bunched or rode up, whether the waistband rolled under a hydration belt, and whether a phone in the pocket bounced or pulled the shorts sideways at speed. Each pair also got a squat test in front of a mirror and a look in direct afternoon sun for sheerness, because a lot of these fabrics are fine indoors and turn transparent the second you sweat.
Sizing got its own pass. I ordered my usual size in every pair and a size up wherever the chart was vague, then measured each inseam against the number on the product page — several were off by an inch or more. Every pair was washed five times and rechecked for fading, stretched elastic, and pilling, and we wore our favorites to coffee and the grocery store to see whether they read as shorts or as underwear. Colors that photographed well but washed out or went sheer didn’t make the cut.
How to Choose Women’s Running Shorts
The right pair is the one you stop noticing by mile three, and the two things that interrupt that most are a hem that creeps and a waistband that migrates.
Pick the Inseam by Your Thigh, Not Your Height
The listed inseam tells you where a hem starts, not where it ends up once you’re moving. A 2.5- or 3-inch short gives the most freedom and the least fabric to soak, but on thicker thighs the hem can migrate inward with every stride. That’s geometry, not a sizing fault, and sizing up rarely fixes it.
Five inches clears the widest part of most thighs, and seven inches is the coverage choice — it does not make you slower, whatever the racing photos suggest. If you’re tall, add an inch to whatever you normally wear, because a short that hits mid-thigh on a five-foot-four runner sits at the widest point on someone five-nine.
Decide What You Want Under the Shell
Liners come in three forms: a built-in brief, a two-in-one with a fitted under short, and nothing at all. The brief is lightest and coolest. The two-in-one is the answer for anyone who chafes, because the under short is what stops thigh meeting thigh, which is why the Stelle is our pick for long, hot efforts.
Here’s the trap: in a two-in-one the liner decides the fit, not the outer shell. If the liner is snug, sizing up hands you a looser shell over the same tight liner. Fit the liner first, and treat the outer layer as decoration.
The Waistband Is Most of the Fit
A wide, high band spreads pressure and stays put without help; a narrower mid-rise band usually needs a drawstring to hold its place. If you run with a phone, lean toward the drawstring, because a loaded side pocket drags an elastic waist down over an hour.
The trade is comfort. Drawstrings bunch under a hydration belt and can dig in late in a long run. Rise matters too: high-rise suits a longer torso, while a short-waisted runner often finds a mid-rise band sits where they expect it to.
One Good Zip Beats Three Flimsy Pockets
Zip pockets are the only ones that keep a phone secure at speed, and a center-back zip is the most stable spot for weight because it doesn’t pull the short sideways. Side pockets are more convenient and carry more, but they swing, which is why the baleaf’s drawstring earns its keep.
Two things to check before ordering: whether the pocket exists on both hips or only one, and whether the opening clears a phone in a case. A small drop-in pocket is fine for a key and useless for anything else.
Fabric and Color Decide What Shows
Lighter knits are cooler and dry faster; heavier ones hide sweat and hold their shape. Neither is automatically better — a midweight knit like the Play Up’s is the friendlier choice for running errands afterward, a thin one for humid intervals.
Color matters more than most shoppers expect. Bright and pale colorways turn sheer under tension, and the same short in black can be perfectly opaque while the neon version is not. If you’re buying a light color, treat opacity as an open question rather than a given.
Frequently Asked Questions
What do you wear under running shorts with a built-in liner?
Nothing. The liner is the underwear, and adding a second layer is what causes the bunching and chafing the liner exists to prevent. If the liner itself rubs, switch to a seamless synthetic brief rather than cotton, which holds moisture against the skin.
The same rule applies to a two-in-one: the fitted under short does the job, so wear it against the skin.
How should I wash quick-dry running shorts?
Cold water, a normal cycle, and no fabric softener — softener coats the fibers and quietly kills wicking. Skip the dryer or use the lowest heat, since heat is what destroys the elastic in a waistband.
Hang them to dry and they’ll be ready overnight, which is one reason a two-pair rotation beats one expensive pair.
How often should running shorts be replaced?
Replace them when the waistband stops snapping back, the liner loses its stretch, or the crotch fabric pills through. Those are the three failure points and none of them is fixed by washing.
Rotating two or three pairs spreads the wear and roughly doubles how long each one lasts.
Can I use running shorts for hiking and gym workouts?
Yes, with one adjustment. For hiking, a five- or seven-inch short sits better under a hipbelt than a 2.5-inch high-rise, which a pack tends to push down.
For lifting, a two-in-one keeps the loose outer layer from catching on a bar, and a zip pocket keeps your phone off the floor.
Final Verdict
Most women should start with the Under Armour Play Up 3.0. Order a size down and you get a short that handles a tempo run, a gym session, and the walk home without asking anything of you.
Two exceptions are worth naming. If you chafe, the Stelle’s under short is the fix, and it costs less than most of this group. If you want coverage, nothing here beats the baleaf at seven inches — that’s the pair for tall runners and long days on trail.