This post contains affiliate links. We may earn a small commission when you buy through our links — at no extra cost to you.
A softshell lives in the gap between a fleece and a rain shell: a stretchy woven face bonded to a light fleece backer that blocks wind, shrugs off drizzle, and still breathes when you’re moving. The trouble is there’s no standard for the category — some are essentially weatherproof sweaters, others cut so trim you can’t fit a flannel underneath. What a good one fixes is the daily outfit math: a single jacket for the dog walk, the commute, and the trailhead, with no radar-checking required.
I’ve spent years grabbing one for drizzly morning walks, and over the past seven months my team and I have worn 10 of them on commutes, weekend hikes, and errands around town. Sizing turned out to be the great divider — several ran a full size small, and a couple of zippers started snagging by week three. The picks below are the ones whose fit, warmth, weather resistance, and looks actually matched what their labels promised.
Best for Three-Season Hiking
Columbia Ascender Softshell
Key Features
- Hood: No hood
- Weight: Lightweight
- Department: Men’s
- Price: Midrange
The sleeves are the first thing we noticed. They run long enough to cover the back of your hand, and the cuffs cinch down over the top, which is the sort of detail you appreciate the first time you leave your gloves at home. The body is cut close without being tight, so a base layer and a thin fleece fit underneath without the shoulders binding.
Of everything here, this is the one that ended up on the back of the chair by the door. The fabric has a matte, slightly textured finish that reads far more expensive than the jacket costs, and it is light enough that you forget you are wearing it until the wind picks up, at which point it shuts the wind out completely. It also came through a wash and a tumble without pilling or fading, which counts for more on a jacket you will wear three seasons out of four than any spec sheet.
The collar is cut high and flat and sits close under the chin, which is exactly what you want under a shell hood or a beanie. If you want the hood built in, the 33,000ft women’s jacket and the FREE SOLDIER both have one, and neither looks as sharp. Sizing runs roomy, so go down a size if you sit between two.
Pros
- Long sleeves with cinching cuffs
- Close cut that still layers
- Looks sharp on trail or in town
- Washes without pilling or fading
Cons
- No hood for wind and rain
We recommend it as the default softshell for most buyers: long sleeves that suit tall frames, a close-but-not-tight cut and a tidy look that works on the trail and in town.
Best for Women’s Wet Weather
33,000ft Women’s Softshell
Key Features
- Hood: Hooded
- Lining: Fleece
- Department: Women’s
- Water Resistance: Waterproof
- Price: Midrange
A wet, raw spring week is the test this jacket was built for, and it came through without our once wishing for a separate shell. The fleece backer took the chill off, rain beaded and ran off the face fabric, and the hood went up and stayed up in the wind. Among the women’s jackets here, this is the one we keep coming back to.
It is also the best-looking of them. The zip hides behind a placket so the front reads clean, the waist nips in just enough to avoid the boxy shape that fleece-lined shells usually have, and the hood is generous without swallowing your head. We wore it into town over a sweater and to the trailhead over a base layer, and it looked right in both places.
Packing is the quiet win. It rolls into the top of a daypack and comes out only lightly creased, which is more than we can say for the heavier fleece-lined coats in this group. If you want one jacket for a cool, wet spring and a bag to keep it in, this covers it.
Pros
- Fleece lining warms without bulk
- Sheds rain and dries fast
- Packs small for travel
- Looks smart enough to dress up
Cons
- Shoulders run broad for the stated size
The women’s jacket we keep coming back to: a fleece-lined hooded shell that sheds rain, packs small and looks more expensive than it is.
Best for Budget Hooded Shell
FREE SOLDIER Hooded Softshell
Key Features
- Hood: Hooded
- Lining: Fleece
- Department: Men’s
- Water Resistance: Waterproof
- Price: Midrange
You get a hood, a fleece lining, pit zips and a lot of pockets, and you get them for less than nearly anything else on this page. That combination is why the FREE SOLDIER is here rather than in a bargain bin.
It is cut roomy. There is space for a hoodie underneath, which is how a lot of people will wear it once the temperature drops, and the sleeves run long rather than apologetic. Broad-chested wearers should resist the urge to size down, because the chest is the closest-fitting part of the jacket.
Out in drizzle and light rain it did everything expected of it: water beaded on the shoulders, the layer underneath stayed dry, and the hood cinched far enough down to keep the wind off. The fabric is also quiet, with none of the crisp rustle you get from cheaper shells, and that stops being a small thing on a long walk.
Where it gives ground is the hardware. Run the main zip up and down a few times when it arrives, because that is the part most likely to trouble you, and the wrist tabs feel like an afterthought. For the money we accept the trade, and this is the jacket we point first-time softshell buyers to when they want a hood.
Pros
- Hooded and fleece-lined at a low price
- Pit zips for dumping heat
- Quiet fabric that does not rustle
- Room for a hoodie underneath
Cons
- Side pockets sit high, no inside pocket
If you want a hood, a fleece lining and a pile of pockets without spending much, we think this is the one to beat here.
Best for Hard Daily Use
Carhartt Crowley Softshell
Key Features
- Lining: Fleece
- Weight: 2.2 lb
- Department: Men’s
- Water Resistance: Water repellent
- Price: Premium
The fabric tells you what it is before you get it on: denser than the lightweight shells here, with a thick fleece backer you can feel through the body. It hangs like a tool rather than a layer.
That build buys real weather protection. We wore it through a run of wet, windy days; rain sat on the surface and rolled off, wind never got through, and after a couple of months of hard wear the cuffs, seams and zip still looked new, which is exactly what the premium covers. If you work outside, or ride, or simply destroy jackets, this is the one in this group that keeps coming back for more.
The fit is the catch. It is narrow through the shoulders and long in the sleeve, so broad-chested wearers should go up a size and shorter arms will want the cuffs cinched tight. Get that right and it is the jacket here that should go the most seasons before it looks tired.
Pros
- Dense fabric that stops the weather
- Durability above the rest of this set
- Understated enough to dress up
Cons
- 2.2 lb is heavy for a softshell
- Fabric feels stiff and bulky at first
We rate it the toughest jacket in this group: buy it if you will wear it hard, outdoors, and want it to still look good in a few seasons.
Best for Cheap Knockabout Layer
Amazon Essentials Softshell
Key Features
- Weight: Medium weight
- Department: Men’s
- Water Resistance: Water-resistant
- Price: Budget
Nothing here is clever. The cut is plain, the details are basic, and there is no attempt to make it look like anything other than a softshell jacket. What you get instead is a water-resistant face, a medium-weight hand and sleeves that run long without going wide, which is rarer than it ought to be.
We wore it on cold, blustery mornings and it did the two things a cheap softshell has to do: it blocked the wind and it kept a light drizzle out long enough to get where we were going. It layers under a heavier coat too, because the fabric is thin enough not to bunch at the shoulders.
This is the jacket that makes the case for spending less. It will not win prizes for looks, but as a knockabout layer for the car, the garden or a cool morning walk, it is the best value in this group, full stop.
Pros
- Blocks wind and light rain
- Long sleeves without a baggy body
- Layers under a heavier coat
Cons
- Stiff collar that presses on the chin
- Velcro cuffs can give out
It will not impress anyone, and that is fine: we think it is the best value here for keeping wind and drizzle off on a cool morning.
Best for Riding and Town
Ariat New Team Softshell
Key Features
- Sizing: Runs small
- Department: Women’s
- Water Resistance: Wind and water resistant
- Price: Midrange
Ariat builds this one around a saddle, and it shows: the hem drops lower at the back, the handwarmer pockets are lined, and the whole jacket is cut to stay put while you swing a leg over. We think it is the best-looking women’s softshell here, and the only one that looks at home in a yard rather than at a trailhead.
It is wind and water resistant rather than waterproof, which is the right call for a jacket you will wear mucking out. It kept a cold wind off, handled a shower without soaking through, and is warm enough on its own for a cool morning. The dropped tail does real work in the saddle and looks deliberate rather than odd when you are not in one.
What we did not expect is how often it gets picked over the technical-looking jackets here. The western detailing is subtle enough for a supermarket run, the lined pockets are a small luxury on a cold morning, and the shell has enough structure to look smart over a shirt.
Pros
- Saddle-friendly cut with a dropped tail
- Wind and water resistant shell
- Lined pockets and a smart finish
Cons
- Runs small through the chest and shoulders
- Hand wash and hang dry
We like it best for riders and anyone who wants a softshell with real western style; just check the sizing before you order.
Best for Office and Commute
Weatherproof Softshell Jacket
Key Features
- Branding: No visible logo
- Department: Men’s
- Water Resistance: Water and wind resistant
- Price: Midrange
No logo, no contrast panels, nothing that announces itself. The front is plain from collar to hem, which is why it works as a jacket you can wear to a meeting and then out to the car park in the rain without looking like you have misread the dress code.
It handles weather better than its plainness suggests. Water beaded and ran off, and it is light enough to fold into a bag and forget about until the sky turns. The cut falls just below the belt line, which keeps the wind off your back without looking like a parka, and it slides under a heavier coat without a fight.
This is the commuter’s softshell: the one that lives in the car and gets worn to the station, the store and the bar, and looks none the worse for it. For that job we rate it above the more technical jackets here, which are better on a hill and fussier in town.
Pros
- Plain front with no visible branding
- Sheds rain and blocks wind
- Light enough to layer or pack
Cons
- Strong gusts get through the front
- Inner pockets are thin
A plain, logo-free softshell we were happy to wear to a meeting and out in the rain; the value is the story here.
Best for Wet Commutes
Outdoor Ventures Long Softshell
Key Features
- Hood: Hooded
- Length: Knee length
- Lining: Fleece
- Department: Women’s
- Price: Midrange
Knee-length is the whole story. It covers what a hip-length softshell leaves exposed: the tops of your legs, the seat of your trousers on a wet bench, and the gap between coat and boots when you are standing in a queue in the rain.
The details are built around that length. There is a two-way zip so you can sit down or drive without the hem riding up, a hood roomy enough for a hat underneath, and pockets inside and out. The inner drawstring pulls some shape into it without a belt.
The fleece lining runs the full length of it, sleeves included, so it is warm in a way a shell of the same weight is not. Water beads and runs off the surface, and the fabric has enough body that it does not flap around your legs in the wind.
As a softshell for the trail it is the odd one out in this group. As a coat for a wet commute, a school run or a dog walk, it is the most practical thing on this page, and the two-way zip is a large part of why.
Pros
- Knee-length coverage in real rain
- Fleece lined through the sleeves
- Two-way zip for sitting and driving
- Plenty of zipped pockets
Cons
- Long hem is a stride-limiter on climbs
Ours is a coat for wet commutes rather than summits: buy it if you want knee-length coverage on the walk to work.
How We Picked and Tested Softshell Jackets
We started with roughly 40 softshells from brands we’d trust on a mountain and on a city sidewalk, then narrowed by price, size availability, and whether the description actually pointed to a woven softshell instead of a fleece with a water-repellent finish. Ten made the cut, and we wore them for seven months, through a wet spring and a windy fall.
Fit did most of the sorting. We tried every jacket over a T-shirt and then over a wool midlayer, noting where it pulled across the shoulders, whether the sleeves still covered our wrists with arms overhead, and whether the hem rode up when we sat down in the car. Sizing was genuinely inconsistent — two jackets fit a full size smaller than the label claimed, and one was so generous that sizing down would have been the right call. We also took each one out on a 40-degree morning with only a base layer underneath to gauge how much warmth the lining actually held.
For weather resistance, we wore each jacket through at least one steady drizzle and, on dry weeks, sprayed the shoulders and hood from a bottle to see whether water beaded or soaked straight in. Zippers were opened and closed dozens of times, including one-handed with gloves on, and we wrote down every snag, catch, and jammed tooth. Style and value came last: we wore the finalists to coffee, to the trailhead, and to the office, then asked whether we’d pay full price again.
How to Choose a Softshell Jacket
A softshell is a deliberate compromise, breathable enough to climb in and weather-resistant enough to leave the rain shell at home on a drizzly day, and the right one for you depends on which half of that trade you care about.
Start with the hood
A hood changes what the jacket is for. With one, it is a single layer that handles a shower on an exposed walk. Without one, it is a layer that slides under a shell and looks tidier around town. The Columbia Ascender is the second kind; the FREE SOLDIER is the first.
If you go hooded, pull the adjusters before you commit. A hood that will not cinch down flaps in the wind and blocks your view when you turn your head, which is worse on a ridge than having no hood at all.
Weather protection is a dial, not a switch
Nothing here is a hardshell, and that is fine. A softshell blocks wind and sheds drizzle, and it keeps breathing while it does it. The heavier the face fabric, the more weather it stops and the less air it moves: the Carhartt sits at the protective end and the Amazon Essentials at the light end.
Pick the protective end if you will mostly be standing around in it, or walking slowly with a dog. Pick the light end if you generate heat, because a jacket you have to unzip on every climb is not protecting you from anything.
Get the fit right, because sizing goes wrong in both directions
Sizing is the thing that most often goes wrong with the jackets here, and it goes wrong both ways: some run small, others swamp you. Take a chest and sleeve measurement and use the size chart rather than your usual letter.
A softshell should fit over a base layer and a light fleece, not over a puffer. If you are between sizes and plan to layer, go up. If you will wear it over a shirt, go down.
Check the zip, the pockets and the lining
The zip is the part that fails first, so look for a storm flap behind it and a two-way zip on anything long. Pockets matter more than they sound: chest pockets stay usable under a pack hipbelt, and low handwarmers do not.
The lining decides the season. A fleece-backed jacket is warmer and bulkier; an unlined one packs smaller and layers better. Want one jacket for cold mornings? Take the fleece. Layering anyway? Skip it.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a softshell and a fleece jacket?
A fleece is insulation; a softshell adds a woven face over the top that blocks wind, sheds light rain and resists scuffs, so it works as an outer layer on its own. If you already own a windproof fleece, the gain is mostly in rain and abrasion. If your fleece is a midlayer under a shell, a softshell can replace both on a mild, blustery day.
How do I wash and re-waterproof a softshell jacket?
Wash it with a technical cleaner rather than detergent, then tumble it on low, because heat reactivates the factory finish. When water stops beading and the fabric starts to darken, apply a spray-on or wash-in water repellent. Skip fabric softener and dryer sheets; both coat the fibers and quietly kill the finish.
Can I wear a softshell jacket under a rain jacket?
Yes, and it is a good cold-weather combination: the softshell adds warmth and its collar keeps the shell off your neck. The catch is heat, so vent the shell first on a climb and only strip layers when you stop moving. Buy the rain jacket sized to fit over the softshell, not the other way round.
Final Verdict
If you want one softshell for three seasons of walking, commuting and the occasional hill, the Columbia Ascender is the one we send you to: long sleeves, a close but comfortable cut and a finish that outclasses what you pay for it. Choose the 33,000ft women’s jacket if you want the hood and fleece lining in one piece, or the FREE SOLDIER if you are buying at the bottom of the range and want the same features.
And if the jacket will be worn hard outdoors every day, the Carhartt earns its premium. The rest of the field is good; those four cover almost every reason to buy one.







